CCTV Quotation Comparison: BOQ, Technical Compliance, Exclusions and Warranty Before Award

CCTV Quotation Comparison: BOQ, Technical Compliance, Exclusions and Warranty Before Award

A CCTV quotation should not be judged on its total. Judge it on four things: is the bill of quantities (BOQ) complete and itemised, are the offered models technically compliant with the required specification, which exclusions will the owner pay for later, and what does the warranty actually cover. This article gives you a practical way to compare CCTV quotations before award, explains when the same method applies to fire system quotations, and shows what a detailed offer from AZEIDK’s technical supply team covers line by line.

Key takeaways

  • Have every contractor price the same layout, the same specification and the same recording retention period, or the comparison is not fair.
  • A good quotation names each camera’s model, resolution, lens and IR range, with the datasheet attached.
  • Hard-disk capacity should come from a written calculation, not a fixed number.
  • Read exclusions before prices: civil works, power points, internet and containment may sit outside the offer.
  • Fire system quotations are compared in a similar way, and have their own article because their items and certificates differ.
In this article
  1. Why do CCTV quotations differ so much between contractors?
  2. How do you set a common basis before asking for quotations?
  3. How do you read the BOQ in a CCTV quotation?
  4. What does technical compliance mean in a CCTV quotation?
  5. Which exclusions should you read before award?
  6. How do you compare warranty and maintenance in CCTV offers?
  7. Are fire system quotations compared the same way?
  8. From comparison to award
  9. Frequently asked questions
  10. Conclusion

Why do CCTV quotations differ so much between contractors?

Two quotations for the same building can be far apart, and the reason is rarely that one contractor is “expensive”. Usually each contractor understood the requirement differently. One offered 2 MP fixed-lens cameras and an NVR that keeps a few days of footage; another offered higher-resolution varifocal cameras and storage sized to the period the regulations require. Both are “a CCTV system”, but they are not the same product.

Common reasons for the gap:

  • Number and placement of cameras, especially when no site survey was done before pricing.
  • System technology: IP or analogue, and the recorders and cables that follow from it. See IP vs analogue CCTV.
  • The assumed recording retention period, which drives the number and size of disks.
  • What the offer includes in containment, switches, rack, UPS and monitors.
  • The brand, and the product line within the brand, since one manufacturer has both value and professional ranges.

How do you set a common basis before asking for quotations?

The best time to solve the comparison problem is before the offers arrive. Send every contractor the same package:

  1. Building drawings with the required camera locations, or ask for a technical site survey before pricing.
  2. The purpose of each camera: motion detection, recognising people, or identifying faces and number plates at entrances.
  3. The required retention period and recording mode (continuous or motion).
  4. Number of monitors, location of the control room, and whether mobile viewing is needed.
  5. Whether the facility falls under the Security Surveillance Cameras Law, since this affects design and documentation. Details are in Saudi CCTV law obligations.

Leave these points open and each contractor will assume whatever suits his price, and you will end up comparing different systems.

How do you read the BOQ in a CCTV quotation?

A one-line offer such as “supply and install a complete CCTV system” cannot be compared and cannot be enforced. Ask for an itemised BOQ and put all offers into one table with these lines:

ItemWhat the offer should stateWhat to watch for
CamerasQuantity per type (bullet, dome, PTZ), model, resolution, lensOne unnamed camera model for every location
NVRChannels, disk bays, modelNo spare channels for future extension
Hard disksNumber, capacity and calculation basis (days, resolution, frame rate)Capacity with no calculation attached
SwitchesPort count, PoE support and total PoE budgetPoE budget below the total camera load
Cables and containmentCable type, approximate lengths, conduit or trunking“As per site” with no quantities
Rack and powerRack, UPS, power point locationsNo UPS at all
Monitors and viewingNumber and size of monitors, viewing software or appUnpriced licences for management software
Programming, testing and handoverCamera set-up, user rights, test record, handover fileTesting and documentation not mentioned

To check the disk line yourself, use the CCTV storage calculator. To check the switch line, see PoE switch power budget for CCTV.

What does technical compliance mean in a CCTV quotation?

Technical compliance means placing the specification of each offered model next to the required specification and checking it against the manufacturer’s official datasheet, not the contractor’s description. Core comparison points for a camera:

  • Resolution and sensor size.
  • Lens type (fixed or varifocal) and the resulting field of view.
  • Night-vision range and technology. See CCTV night vision.
  • WDR for entrances with strong backlight.
  • Ingress protection (IP rating) for outdoor cameras, which matters in Saudi dust and heat.
  • Supported compression (H.264 or H.265), since it affects storage.
  • Video analytics where required, such as person and vehicle detection. See AI CCTV cameras.

If a contractor offers an “equivalent” alternative brand, ask for a line-by-line compliance sheet with datasheets. CCTV brands available from AZEIDK include Hikvision, Dahua, Bosch and EZVIZ; you can review models on the product pages and on the Hikvision and Dahua brand pages.

Which exclusions should you read before award?

Exclusions are where the price difference disappears. A slightly cheaper offer may leave out items the owner pays for later. Look for these in every offer and ask who does them and who pays:

  • Civil works: chasing, making good and painting after cabling.
  • Power points at camera or rack locations.
  • Poles and foundations for outdoor cameras.
  • Internet subscription and remote-viewing set-up.
  • Lifts or scaffolding for high mounting points.
  • Connection or documentation requirements imposed by the authorities on facilities covered by the law.
  • Any extension or layout change after award, and how it will be priced.

How do you compare warranty and maintenance in CCTV offers?

“One-year warranty” on its own is not enough. Ask five questions:

  1. Does it cover equipment only, or equipment, installation and labour?
  2. Does it start from delivery or from the signed acceptance date?
  3. Are hard disks covered for the same period?
  4. What is the response time for a fault, and is replacement stock held locally?
  5. What voids it, such as work by another party on the system or power faults?

After the warranty comes the maintenance contract. Compare what it includes and the number of visits. Note that fire system maintenance and CCTV maintenance are two separate contracts, never one combined contract.

Are fire system quotations compared the same way?

The principle is the same: one basis, an itemised BOQ, technical compliance, exclusions and warranty. Fire system offers, however, carry items CCTV does not, such as UL listing or FM approval of components, certificates of conformity through the SABER platform for extinguishing equipment and fire pumps, the submittal to the consultant, and Civil Defense requirements. That is why they have their own article: How to compare fire system quotations between contractors. If your project includes both systems, ask for a separate offer for each so the comparison stays clear.

From comparison to award

  1. Put all offers into one comparison table with the same item order.
  2. Send each contractor written questions on missing or unclear items.
  3. Ask for a revised offer on the same basis after the answers.
  4. Fix the approved models in the purchase order, and attach the datasheets, the storage calculation and the acceptance test template.

The last step protects you on handover day, because testing and acceptance will measure the system against what the approved offer says.

Frequently asked questions

How many CCTV quotations should I compare?

Three offers on the same basis are usually enough to see the reasonable range. What matters is that they are detailed and comparable, not how many you collect.

Is the cheapest CCTV quotation the best one?

Not necessarily. Compare models, retention period, exclusions and warranty first, then compare price between offers that match on these points.

What should a CCTV installation quotation include?

An itemised BOQ with models and quantities, the storage calculation, containment, switches and rack, programming, testing and handover, plus a list of exclusions and warranty terms.

Should the quotation name the camera model?

Yes. Without a specific model you cannot check resolution, night vision or IP rating, and you cannot compare the offer with others.

Why does hard-disk capacity differ between offers?

Each contractor assumed a different retention period, resolution or recording mode. Ask for the calculation basis in writing in every offer.

Should I ask for one quotation covering CCTV and fire systems?

A separate offer for each system is better, because their items, certificates and approval routes differ, which makes comparison and accountability easier.

Conclusion

Comparing CCTV quotations starts before the offers arrive: one pricing basis, then an itemised BOQ, then technical compliance from the datasheets, then exclusions and warranty. Only then does the total become useful information.

Need an itemised CCTV quotation? The AZEIDK team prepares a BOQ with models, storage calculation and clear exclusions. Talk to the AZEIDK team

References: Security Surveillance Cameras Law (Royal Decree M/34 dated 7/3/1444 AH) and its implementing regulation, Umm Al-Qura Gazette (in Arabic); SASO Technical Regulation for Fire Control Materials and Equipment; AZEIDK product and service pages.
Share this article
This site is registered on wpml.org as a development site. Switch to a production site key to remove this banner.